I suppose a base question to ask would be "Why does the EPA hate coal?"
According to the EPA, existing power plants account for 38% of existing CO2 emissions. Of these, a majority of the emissions come from coal-fired power plants, specifically AGING coal-fired power plants, at about 30% of existing CO2 emissions.
Furthermore, according to the EPA, the U.S. coal-fired fleet is nearly half a century old, with an average age of 42 years old. According to the Sierra Club, of the 593 coal-fired power plants, 63% are over 40 years old! Based on the idea of increased efficiency over time, this means a majority of coal-based plants are incredibly inefficient.
Yet, is that enough?
According to the US Chamber of Commerce, these regulations could cost businesses $28 billion a year in compliance costs through 2030, and could also cost 450,000 jobs by 2020. Of course, this also was completed under the strictest plan the EPA proposed, not the one currently going into effect. As such, actual numbers are likely lower.
Indeed, the EPA states that costs will be far lower, with businesses paying only $7.3 to 8.8 billion a year in compliance costs through 2030. This goes to $65 per household (per year in costs through 2030). As for jobs, they estimate 72,000 to 78,000 jobs lost through 2025. (Related, they also say that the regulations will provide 76,000 to 112,000 jobs in more environmentally-friendly positions. Even better, research has suggested that "green jobs" are more accessible to those without training or college degrees!)
So that's why coal is being targeted so harshly. It's just a matter of deciding if it's worth it.
Tuesday, October 14, 2014
Monday, October 13, 2014
Effects on Coal - A Rise in Prices?!
It's a fact that regulations impact prices, for better or worse. So it's only natural that the EPA's new standards will affect coal prices (and therefore electricity prices).
After all, the regulations, according to the EPA, are expected to force about 19% of the current coal-fired power plant force to shut down and decrease coal consumption by around 28%. In turn, it's expected that this will rise electricity prices by around 6.5% by 2020.
"Under the provisions of this rule, EPA projects that approximately 46 to 49 GW of additional coal-fired generation (19% of the current capacity, 4.6% of generation capacity in 2020) may be removed from operation by 2020."
Some fear this may lead to a price hike of up to 150% for natural gas.
According to the Department of Energy, there is a distinct possibility that electricity prices could rise by 80%, at least at first. “The precise number will vary, but for first generation we project $70 to $90 per ton [on the wholesale price of electricity],” Julio Friedmann, of the Department of Energy, said. “For second generation, it will be more like a $40 to $50 per ton price. Second generation of demonstrations will begin in a few years, but won’t be until middle of the next decade that we will have lessons learned and cost savings.”
So will these new regulations put electricity in a sleeper hold and force you to dole out more dough for the basics? Well... like all things, it depends. For some regions, there little use of coal, so the effects will be far less. It also depends greatly on the economy's whims, such as with other energy sources, such as natural gas. That said, the EPA has stated that the worst hit area will likely be the Midwest.
But what about Arizona prices? Well, depending on the source, it could be as much as a price raise of up to 31%. Is that true? Honestly, it's hard to be positive until we actually take action. But hey, it's not like the reason why coal's price is so low because of government subsidies. But that's enough for one post. We'll go deeper into jobs and subsidies later!
![]() |
| Like Cthulhu, you need to just accept this fact. |
"Under the provisions of this rule, EPA projects that approximately 46 to 49 GW of additional coal-fired generation (19% of the current capacity, 4.6% of generation capacity in 2020) may be removed from operation by 2020."
Some fear this may lead to a price hike of up to 150% for natural gas.
According to the Department of Energy, there is a distinct possibility that electricity prices could rise by 80%, at least at first. “The precise number will vary, but for first generation we project $70 to $90 per ton [on the wholesale price of electricity],” Julio Friedmann, of the Department of Energy, said. “For second generation, it will be more like a $40 to $50 per ton price. Second generation of demonstrations will begin in a few years, but won’t be until middle of the next decade that we will have lessons learned and cost savings.”
So will these new regulations put electricity in a sleeper hold and force you to dole out more dough for the basics? Well... like all things, it depends. For some regions, there little use of coal, so the effects will be far less. It also depends greatly on the economy's whims, such as with other energy sources, such as natural gas. That said, the EPA has stated that the worst hit area will likely be the Midwest.
But what about Arizona prices? Well, depending on the source, it could be as much as a price raise of up to 31%. Is that true? Honestly, it's hard to be positive until we actually take action. But hey, it's not like the reason why coal's price is so low because of government subsidies. But that's enough for one post. We'll go deeper into jobs and subsidies later!
Wednesday, October 8, 2014
What the CPP means for AZ
Now that we have a basis for natural gas, next comes the big question of what the impact of the EPA’s Clean Power Plan (CPP) will have on the natural gas industry in Arizona. The CPP seeks to reduce nationwide carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions by 30% by 2030 and has state-specific reduction targets for carbon dioxide reductions. For Arizona, the reduction target is 52% by 2030, which is the second highest target in the nation.
To achieve this reduction, EPA offers states four building blocks to choose from. These building blocks are meant to offer flexibility. The four building blocks are: (1) improve the efficiency of fossil-fueled power plants; (2) use of lower-emitting generation sources such as natural gas, or fuel-switching to natural gas, and use of nuclear power; (3) demand-side efficiency; and (4) renewable electric generation.
For Arizona, the building block that offers the greatest reduction of CO2 is from building block 2, switching from coal-fired power plants to natural gas-fired power plants, as stated from Henry Darwin, director of the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality.
For Arizona, the building block that offers the greatest reduction of CO2 is from building block 2, switching from coal-fired power plants to natural gas-fired power plants, as stated from Henry Darwin, director of the Arizona Department of Environmental Quality.
What does that mean for the state of Arizona? Well, the trend of natural gas without the proposed CPP was already projected in increase nationwide. The CPP acts as another driver to increase the demand for natural gas. The increase in demand will eventually lead to higher natural gas prices for consumers. Since there will be a decrease in demand for coal, production in coal will lower resulting in a loss of jobs in the coal industry. While it looks like natural gas producers will be in a winning situation with the Clean Power Plan, the environmental impacts associated with hydraulic fracking should be assessed.
If Arizona implements building block 2, is the shift from coal to natural gas feasible? For Arizona, this is a complex question. Increasing demand for natural gas production will create many issues which will impact:
- natural gas infrastructure
- transmission
- electric reliability
![]() |
| Generation from both AZ's coal and natural gas plants is not interchangeable given the distance between existing plants resulting in transmission and reliability concerns.
Additionally, there are issues for the state of Arizona and its role as an electricity supplier. According to the EIA, Arizona generates more electricity than it consumes. It is an exporter of electricity supplying electricity for El Paso, Texas and Los Angeles, California. If Arizona switches to using more natural gas, Arizona may no longer be an exporter of electricity as Arizona gets about ⅖ of its electricity from coal.
|
![]() |
| Most of the electricity that AZ generates is from coal-fired power plants. |
Tuesday, October 7, 2014
What's Trending? Natural Gas!
As we explore the use of natural gas, it’s important to look at the trend and projections of natural gas and the energy market. According to the Energy Information Administration’s (EIA) Annual Energy Outlook 2014 report, natural gas grows by an average rate of 1.6% per year from 2012 to 2040.
Consumption of natural gas grows in the industrial sector by about 2 Tcf and electric power sector by about 2.5 Tcf. These increases in consumption are based on low natural gas prices and the ability of natural gas to replace retired coal-fired power plants.
Across the board, natural gas is projected to increase for end-users except in the residential consumption sector. This slow gradual decrease is expected with improvements in appliance efficiency and as populations shift towards warmer regions.
The top four electric associations to increase in consumption in the electric power sector are SERC Reliability Corporation (SERC), Reliability First Corportation (RFC), Western Electricity Coordinating Council (WECC), and Texas Reliability Entity (TRE). SERC and RFC's projected consumption in natural gas increases due to the retirement of coal-fired power plants. WECC and TRE's projected natural gas consumption increases due to projected growth in electricity demand.
Where will the natural gas come from, you might ask? Well, the EIA projects that natural gas will come primarily from Shale Gas with a 56% increase from 2012-2040.
EIA's overall projections for natural gas look good. Looking at the projections, can you see natural gas a a viable fuel for the future? What other factors may influence these trends?
My next blog post will cover the proposed EPA’s Clean Power Plan, and how that may affect natural gas production and consumption.
Friday, October 3, 2014
Power Plants from Space
Another quick post.
It's often said that the Great Wall of China can be seen from space. While this might not be true, it is a fact that we can see other man-made products. Did you know that you can see coal-fired power plants from space? It's true! Below is a still image with a red lined plume from one of the three visible plants.
Though since that's a bit hard to make out, here's the full-size gif.
It's often said that the Great Wall of China can be seen from space. While this might not be true, it is a fact that we can see other man-made products. Did you know that you can see coal-fired power plants from space? It's true! Below is a still image with a red lined plume from one of the three visible plants.
Infrared Imagery from GOES13 Satellite
Thursday, October 2, 2014
Natural Gas 101
So how do we get natural gas from the ground? There are two processes I will discuss, hydraulic fracturing and horizontal drilling. These processes are used simultaneously. Hydraulic fracturing, aka fracking, is a method that stimulates the flow of natural gas in ground rock formations.Typically, a well is drilled vertically several thousands of feet underground to the designated rock formation (usually shale), and laid horizontally, which is horizontal drilling. Then fluid, which consists of water, sand, and certain additives, is pumped through the well at high pressure to open up rock fractures in the designated rock formation. The internal pressure causes fluid to be sent to the surface. Presto! We have natural gas.
Horizontal drilling allows for a multitude of vertical wells to be drilled from a single well pad. These wells fan out upon reaching the specified layer of rock formation allowing for an increase of natural gas production from a single well pad.
According to the U.S. Energy Information Administration, in 2012 Arizona produced 117 million cu ft. of natural gas. More than two-thirds of natural gas is used in the power sector in Arizona, while the other third is used in the residential sector. In 2012, Arizona consumed 339.1 trillion btu of natural gas. Arizona does not have an underground natural gas storage facility so most of the natural gas that is used in Arizona is imported. The two primary rock formations that supply natural gas for Arizona are the San Juan Basin in New Mexico and the Permian Basin in Texas. The natural gas is imported through interstate natural gas pipelines.
![]() |
| Source: Our Environment |
Here is a picture from the Energy Information Administration on natural gas power plants, depicted by the blue flame, and interstate pipelines in Arizona.
| Source: Energy Information Administration |
This picture depicts the United States' natural gas pipelines in 2007 and the states that are dependent on interstate natural gas pipelines as their primary supply of natural gas. The grey states represent dependent states.
![]() |
| Source: Energy Information Administration |
Upcoming blog: Trends of natural gas, and the potential impact of the EPA's proposed Clean Power Plan ruling on natural gas.
Shut-Down of Arizona's Generators
Before 2012, there were 8 such power plants: Abitibi Snowflake Power Plant, Apache Generating Station, Cholla Power Plant, Coronado Generating Station, Four Corners Generating Station, H. Wilson Sundt Generating Station, Navajo Generating Station, and Springerville Generating Station.
In October of 2012, Abitibi Snowflake Power Plant was closed. In September of 2013, Navajo Generating Station began consideration of shutting down one of its three units. In December of the same year, Four Corners shut down three of its five units. This past September, Cholla plans to close one of its four units and Apache has just had it's plan to convert one unit to natural gas approved by the EPA, and even more changes are exceedingly likely (or have just been accidentally skipped over! Oops!).
Of these examples, all but Abitibi Snowflake is related to changing regulations under the EPA, under the goal of reducing carbon dioxide emissions from existing power plants by 30% (of 2005 levels) by 2030. Related, I feel the need to point the word "existing" in that sentence.
Needless to say, it is obvious that the face of coal is changing, for better or worse. I hope to take a more in-depth look at this in the near-future.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









